4 E San Carlos Avenue, St. Augustine, FL, 32084

Open House Sun, Sep 27th 01:00 PM - 03:00 PM

Address

4 E San Carlos Avenue, St. Augustine, FL

Listing Type

Active

Price

$ 1,050,000

Property Attributes

MLS#2163379
TypeSingle Family
Listing Status Active
CountySAINT JOHNS
CitySt. Augustine
Area322-Downtown St Augustine
NeighborhoodNelmar Terrace
Zip32084
StyleCraftsman,Traditional
Year Built2017
Taxes$ 14615
Price$ 1,050,000
Bedrooms4
Full Bathrooms3
Half Bathrooms1
Sqr Footage2772
Lot Size0.28 Acres

Data Source:

Northeast Florida MLS (NEFMLS)

Property Description

A distinctive St. Augustine home in a location that lets you experience the city--not simply live near it. Set in the sought-after Uptown/Nelmar Terrace area, 4 E San Carlos Ave captures the character that makes St. Augustine so desirable: mature oaks draped in Spanish moss, palms, charming architecture, and the ability to move easily between the historic city, local dining and shops, waterfront activities, and the beaches beyond. From the street, the home's coastal-inspired architecture, metal roof, welcoming covered front porch, and mature landscape immediately set it apart. Inside, the home offers four bedrooms, three-and-a-half baths, and a spacious bonus/game room, creating a versatile layout for full-time living, welcoming family and friends, or simply enjoying a home with room to spread out. The main living spaces are bright and inviting, with an open-concept design connecting the living room and beautifully appointed kitchen. White cabinetry, quartz-style countertops, stainless appliances, a detailed glass-tile backsplash, and a large island create a kitchen that is both functional and polished. A walk-in pantry adds valuable storage, while a separate, cozy office provides a quiet space for working from home, reading, or simply having a dedicated place to retreat. A fireplace adds warmth and character to the living space, creating a natural gathering place for everyday life and entertaining. Upstairs, the primary suite offers a private retreat complete with its own balcony, creating a quiet place to enjoy the morning or unwind in the evening. The bonus/game room adds an entirely different dimension to the home--ideal for recreation, movie nights, guests, or simply giving everyone a little more room to spread out. Outdoor living is one of this home's defining features. Rather than one ordinary backyard, the property offers multiple distinct spaces to enjoy the outdoors, including the covered front porch, rear porch, private primary-suite balcony, and a beautifully designed pavered courtyard alongside the home. Tropical landscaping, comfortable seating, and a dedicated grilling area create an intimate setting for morning coffee, evening gatherings, or entertaining friends, while additional lawn areas provide even more room to enjoy the Florida sunshine. The home is equally well suited to everyday practicality, with an extended driveway, 2.5-car garage, no HOA, and a generator inlet. There is room for vehicles, storage, bikes, a golf cart, and the extras that come with enjoying the Florida lifestyle. And then there's the location. Historic St. Augustine becomes part of everyday life here. Walk to iconic landmarks and museums, the Fountain of Youth, and beautiful oak-canopied Magnolia Avenue, where centuries-old live oaks draped in Spanish moss create one of the city's most memorable settings. From here, historic streets, local restaurants, galleries, shops, and the waterfront are all part of the experience, while a bike ride opens the door to even more--from downtown to the coast and beaches beyond. The surrounding mature trees and distinctive mix of homes add to the character of a neighborhood that feels authentically St. Augustine--a place where history, natural beauty, and coastal living are woven into everyday life. Some homes are best understood in person. Come experience the setting, walk the porches, step into the courtyard, take in the surrounding character, and discover what makes 4 E San Carlos Ave a truly special St. Augustine offering. Schedule your private showing today.

Elementary School	Middle School	High School
Ketterlinus Elementary School	Sebastian Middle School	St. Augustine High School

Price History
9/3/2026	Listed $1,050,000

General Features

Sewer	Public Sewer
Heating	Central
Cooling	Central Air
Utilities	Cable Available,Electricity Connected,Sewer Connected,Water Connected,Propane
Possession	Close Of Escrow
Roof	Metal
Appliances	Dishwasher,Disposal,Dryer,Electric Range,Microwave,Refrigerator,Washer
Garage Spaces	2.5
Patio/Porch Features	Covered,Front Porch,Rear Porch
Architectural Style	Craftsman,Traditional
Construction Materials	Composition Siding,Fiber Cement
Year Built	2017
View	Trees/Woods
Stories Count	2
Levels	Two
Property Subtype	Single Family Residence
Tax Year	2025
Current Use	Residential,Single Family
Parcel Number	1538700000
Community Features	Sidewalks,Fishing,Street Lights,Restaurant
County	St. Johns
Property Type	Residential
HOA	No
Attached Garage	Yes
Subdivision Name	Nelmar Terrace
Garage Y/N	Yes
Other Structures	Shed(s)
Full Baths	3
Status	Active
Directions	Take Exit 318 off I-95 and turn east onto FL-16 E (signs for St. Augustine/Flager College). Follow FL-16 E straight for approximately 5.5 miles. Turn right onto San Marco Avenue (US-1 S/FL-16 E split
High School	St. Augustine
City	St. Augustine
Senior Community Y/N	No
Zoning Description	Residential
MLS Area	322-Downtown St Augustine
Lot Size Units	Acres
Lot Size Square Feet	12196.8
Carport Y/N	No
Listing Terms	Cash,Conventional,FHA,VA Loan
Elementary School	Ketterlinus
Property Attached Y/N	No
Tax Annual Amount	14615.51
Home Warranty Y/N	No
Middle/Junior High School	Sebastian
Lease Renewal Y/N	No
MLS Area Minor	322-Downtown St Augustine
Lease Considered Y/N	No
Rent Control Y/N	No
Standard Status	Active
MobileHomeRemainsYN	No
Cash	True
Conventional	True
Sewer_co_Public_sp_Sewer	True
Heating_co_Central	True
Utilities_co_Cable_sp_Available	True
Accessory Dwelling Unit Y/N	No
Water Body Access Y/N	None
CDD	No

Interior Features

Interior Amenities	Ceiling Fan(s),Entrance Foyer,Guest Suite,Kitchen Island,Open Floorplan,Pantry,Primary Bathroom - Shower No Tub
Furnished Y/N	Furnished
Total Fireplaces	1
Fireplace Features	Gas
Basement (Y/N)	No
Air Conditioning Y/N	Yes
Heating Y/N	Yes
Fireplace Y/N	Yes
Half Baths	1
Laundry Features	Electric Dryer Hookup,In Unit,Upper Level,Washer Hookup
Total Bedrooms	4
Entry Level	1
LivingAreaSource	Public Records
Total Baths	4

Exterior Features

Exterior Amenities	Balcony,Courtyard
Fencing	Back Yard,Wire,Wood
Parking Features	Additional Parking,Attached,Garage,Garage Door Opener,Gated,RV Access/Parking
Lot Features	Cul-De-Sac,Dead End Street
Water Source	Public
Lot Size Area	0.28
Spa	No
Building Area Total	3704.0
Lot Size Acres	0.28
Road Surface Type	Paved
Waterfront Y/N	No
Crops Included Y/N	No
Horse Y/N	No
Irrigation Water Rights Y/N	No
Exterior_sp_Features_co_Balcony	True